A construction contractor in Michigan thought he was doing timekeeping right. His crews filled out timesheets. He paid overtime when it was obvious. He kept records — at least, he thought he did.
Then the Department of Labor showed up.
The investigation found systemic overtime violations and improper timekeeping practices — including rounding methods that consistently shortchanged workers. The result: $594,143 in back wages and liquidated damages for 59 employees.
That's not an outlier. In 2024, the DOL concluded over 17,000 cases against employers for wage and hour violations, and construction companies faced some of the steepest penalties of any industry. Another contractor paid $143,655 for failing to pay overtime and keep accurate records. A third lost a $2.3 million government contract opportunity because of prior compliance failures.
The common thread? They all violated the same set of rules. Rules that every contractor should know but most don't.
Here's exactly what the Department of Labor requires when it comes to time clocks, timekeeping, and paying your crew.
What the FLSA Requires (And Doesn't Require)
The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) is the federal law that governs how employers track time and pay workers. It's enforced by the DOL's Wage and Hour Division, and it applies to virtually every construction company in the country.
Here's what surprises most contractors: the FLSA doesn't actually require you to use a specific timekeeping method. No punch clocks required. No specific software. No particular form.
What it does require is accurate records.
Records You Must Keep for Every Non-Exempt Employee
Under 29 CFR Part 516, employers must maintain these records for each non-exempt (hourly) worker:
- Full name and Social Security number
- Home address, including ZIP code
- Date of birth (if under 19)
- Sex and occupation
- Day and hour the workweek begins
- Hours worked each day and total hours each workweek
- Basis of pay (e.g., "$28/hour")
- Regular hourly rate for any week overtime is worked
- Total straight-time earnings per day or week
- Total overtime pay for the workweek
- Total wages paid each pay period
- Payment date and pay period covered
- Additions to or deductions from wages
That's 13 data points per worker, per pay period. Miss any of them, and you're out of compliance.
How Long You Must Keep Records
The FLSA has two retention requirements:
| Record Type | Retention Period |
|---|---|
| Payroll records, collective bargaining agreements, sales records | 3 years |
| Time cards, work schedules, wage computation records | 2 years |
These records must be available for inspection by the DOL at any time. "I lost them" is not a defense — it's actually worse than that. If an employee files a wage claim and you can't produce records to refute it, courts apply the "best evidence" rule: the employee's account of hours worked is presumed correct.
In other words, no records = you lose.
The 6 Time Clock Rules That Trip Up Contractors
Rule 1: You Must Pay for All Time "Suffered or Permitted" to Work
This is the most misunderstood rule — and the one that generates the most DOL violations in construction.
Under the FLSA, if you know or should know that an employee is working, you must pay for that time. Period. It doesn't matter if:
- You didn't authorize the overtime
- The employee chose to start early
- The work was "voluntary"
- They didn't clock in
If a worker arrives at the job site 15 minutes early and starts loading materials, those 15 minutes are compensable. If a foreman stays late to lock up and secure equipment, that's paid time. If a worker answers a phone call about tomorrow's job at 9 PM, that could be compensable too.
What this means for contractors: You need a system that captures actual start and end times, not just scheduled hours. Paper timesheets that only list "7:00 AM - 3:30 PM" every day for weeks on end are a red flag in a DOL audit.
Rule 2: The 7-Minute Rule Isn't What You Think
You've probably heard of the "7-minute rule." Many contractors assume it means workers can clock in up to 7 minutes late without it affecting their pay. That's not what it says.
The 7-minute rule is actually a rounding guideline under 29 CFR § 785.48(b). Here's how it actually works:
When rounding to the nearest quarter-hour (15-minute increment):
| Minutes Past the Quarter-Hour | What Happens |
|---|---|
| 1 to 7 minutes | Rounds down (not counted) |
| 8 to 14 minutes | Rounds up (counted as full quarter-hour) |
So if a worker clocks in at 7:07, their time rounds down to 7:00. If they clock in at 7:08, it rounds up to 7:15.
But here's the critical part: This rounding must be neutral over time. It can't consistently favor the employer. The DOL's exact language:
"This practice of computing working time will be accepted, provided that it is used in such a manner that it will not result, over a period of time, in failure to compensate the employees properly for all the time they have actually worked."
If your rounding policy always rounds employee arrival time down and departure time down (or just rounds down in general), you're violating the FLSA — even if each individual adjustment is only a few minutes.
That Michigan contractor who paid $594,143? Improper rounding was one of the key violations.
Rule 3: Overtime Rules Are Non-Negotiable
Under federal law, non-exempt employees must receive 1.5x their regular rate for every hour worked over 40 in a single workweek. There is no exception for construction, no exception for small businesses, and no exception for "agreed-upon" straight-time arrangements.
Common overtime mistakes contractors make:
Paying overtime after 80 hours biweekly instead of 40 hours weekly. If a worker logs 45 hours in week one and 35 hours in week two, you owe 5 hours of overtime — even though the biweekly total is 80 hours.
Not including all compensation in the regular rate. Bonuses, shift differentials, and certain non-discretionary payments must be factored into the overtime rate. If you pay a $200 weekly production bonus, that changes the overtime math.
Misclassifying workers as exempt. Construction foremen and project managers are frequently misclassified as "salaried exempt." Unless they meet the FLSA's specific salary and duties tests, they're entitled to overtime. The 2024 salary threshold for exemption is $844/week ($43,888/year).
Failing to track overtime for workers at multiple job sites. If the same worker puts in 25 hours at one site and 20 hours at another in the same week, that's 45 hours — and 5 hours of overtime.
Rule 4: You Must Track Break Time Correctly
The FLSA has specific rules about when break time is paid vs. unpaid:
Short breaks (5-20 minutes): Must be paid as working time. This includes coffee breaks, restroom breaks, and smoke breaks. You cannot deduct these from an employee's hours.
Meal periods (30+ minutes): Can be unpaid — but only if the employee is completely relieved of all duties. If a worker eats lunch but stays at the forklift in case they're needed, that's paid time.
Here's where construction companies get in trouble: automatically deducting 30 minutes for lunch from every shift, whether the worker actually took a full, uninterrupted lunch or not.
If your timekeeping system shows an automatic 30-minute deduction every day, the DOL will ask for proof that workers were actually relieved of duties during that time. Without a system that tracks when workers leave and return to the work area, you don't have that proof.
Rule 5: Travel Time Rules Apply to Your Crews
This one catches a lot of contractors off guard. Under the FLSA:
Normal commute (home to first job site, last job site to home): Generally not paid time.
Travel between job sites during the workday: Paid time.
Travel to a different city for a temporary assignment: The time beyond the normal commute is paid time.
Riding in a company vehicle to a job site from a central meeting point: Generally paid time — because the travel benefits the employer, not the employee.
If your crews meet at the shop at 6:30 AM, load the truck, drive 45 minutes to the job site, and don't start the time clock until arrival — you likely owe them for that drive time.
Rule 6: Record Falsification Has Serious Consequences
Telling employees to clock out and keep working is illegal. Instructing a foreman to "adjust" timesheets is illegal. Automatically capping hours at 40 when workers actually worked more is illegal.
These aren't just FLSA violations — they can rise to criminal fraud charges under federal law. Penalties include:
| Violation Type | Potential Penalty |
|---|---|
| First-time FLSA violation | Back wages + liquidated damages (double back pay) |
| Repeated or willful violation | Up to $2,515 per violation (2025 rates) |
| Government contract fraud (False Claims Act) | $11,000-$27,000 per false claim + treble damages |
| Criminal willful violation | Up to $10,000 fine and/or imprisonment |
And those are just the federal penalties. Many states pile on additional fines, and California, New York, and Illinois are especially aggressive about enforcement.
What Happens During a DOL Audit
Understanding what triggers an audit — and what investigators look for — helps you prepare.
What Triggers an Investigation
The DOL's Wage and Hour Division investigates construction companies based on:
- Employee complaints — the most common trigger
- Industry-targeted sweeps — construction is a priority industry for the DOL
- Referrals from other agencies (OSHA, IRS, state labor departments)
- Tips from competitors, subcontractors, or former employees
- Patterns from prior violations
What Investigators Look For
During an audit, the DOL will typically request:
- Time records for all non-exempt employees (going back 2-3 years)
- Payroll records showing wages paid and overtime calculations
- Employee classification documentation (exempt vs. non-exempt)
- Written policies on rounding, overtime, breaks, and travel time
- Proof that your timekeeping system accurately captures hours worked
They'll compare your records to employee interviews. If there's a discrepancy — say your records show everyone worked exactly 40 hours every week but employees report working 45-50 — that's strong evidence of a violation.
The Cost of Getting Caught
Beyond the fines and back wages, a DOL violation can:
- Trigger follow-up audits for years afterward
- Result in injunctions requiring court-approved compliance programs
- Disqualify you from government contracts (this alone can be a death sentence for many construction businesses)
- Become public record — your competitors, clients, and potential employees can see it
- Invite class-action lawsuits from other current or former employees
How to Stay Compliant: A Contractor's Checklist
Here's a practical framework for DOL compliance, specifically designed for construction operations.
1. Use a Timekeeping System That Captures Actual Hours
The single most important step. Your system should record:
- ✅ Exact clock-in and clock-out times (not rounded, not estimated)
- ✅ Location verification (proving the worker was actually at the job site)
- ✅ Break start and end times
- ✅ Travel between job sites
- ✅ All hours across all job sites per worker per week
Paper timesheets fail on almost every one of these. A GPS-verified time tracking app handles all of them automatically.
2. Establish a Written Overtime Policy
Your policy should clearly state:
- Overtime is paid at 1.5x for all hours over 40 per workweek
- Workers must never be asked to work off the clock
- All hours must be accurately reported, even if not pre-authorized
- The process for requesting and approving overtime in advance
3. Audit Your Rounding Practices
If you round time, do a quarterly analysis:
- Pull 3 months of time records
- Compare actual vs. rounded hours for each employee
- Calculate the net effect — does rounding consistently reduce total hours?
- If rounding trends toward underpayment, switch to exact-time recording
Better yet: stop rounding entirely. Modern time tracking apps make rounding unnecessary.
4. Review Your Worker Classifications
Audit every position for correct FLSA classification:
- Does the worker earn at least $844/week on a salary basis?
- Do their primary duties qualify as executive, administrative, or professional?
- If both answers aren't clearly "yes," the worker is non-exempt and must receive overtime
5. Train Your Supervisors
Your foremen and site supervisors are your first line of defense. Make sure they understand:
- They cannot ask workers to work off the clock
- They cannot alter time records after the fact
- They must report all hours worked, including unauthorized overtime
- They are personally liable if they participate in timecard fraud
6. Keep Records Organized and Accessible
- Digital records are better than paper (searchable, harder to lose, easier to produce)
- Back up records regularly
- Maintain records for at least 3 years (some states require longer)
- Have a plan for producing records quickly if the DOL requests them
The Bottom Line
The Department of Labor's time clock rules aren't complicated — but they are strict. And construction is one of the industries the DOL watches most closely.
The companies that get caught aren't usually trying to break the law. They're using paper timesheets that can't prove accuracy. They're rounding time in ways they don't realize favor the company. They're auto-deducting lunch breaks that workers don't fully take. They're miscalculating overtime because they're tracking biweekly instead of weekly.
The fix is straightforward: use a timekeeping system that captures exact, verified hours. GPS-verified time tracking eliminates the guesswork and gives you audit-ready records that prove compliance. Workers clock in when they arrive at the job site — verified by location — and clock out when they leave. Breaks are tracked. Overtime is calculated automatically. Every record is digital, timestamped, and searchable.
You get accurate payroll. Your workers get paid fairly. And when the DOL comes knocking, you hand over records that speak for themselves.
Ready to see how GPS-verified time tracking keeps you DOL-compliant? Book a free demo and we'll walk you through it.

Written by Carter Mitchell
Carter is the founder of Crewtrace. He built Crewtrace to help construction and field service companies eliminate payroll leaks, automate GPS time tracking, and protect their bottom line.
Stop the payroll leakage today.
Book a free demo and see exactly how Crewtrace can save your business thousands of dollars every single month.
